It has been a while, since my last post, and that is because I was very very busy the last week. Busy because I had guests at home, and guests who have left me completely disenchanted and disillusioned. I have known them a while, but this was the first time that we stayed together.I think that is what brought out many ugly truths, about the reality of the urban Indian woman to me. I could not quite accept what I saw, but I cannot dismiss the truth and reality of it all either.
I have always believed that degrees and qualifications, do not necessarily ensure an open accepting mind, and my belief was strongly re-enforced by what I observed during their stay here. She is a doctor, who cooks and cleans and cares for her husband and son. She works and earns too. Quite like me, except for the working bit I had thought, but that is exactly where the similarities end. She does not have control over her bank accounts, or even her ATM card. I could not believe it.Really could not, how can one earn money and have no control over he earning, that is just unreal to me. What is economic independence, if your finances are not under your control. After living in the world of blogs the past few months, where women proudly hold on to their maiden surname post marriage, this was a real shock to me. She is a doctor for heaven's sake, not the maid, whose drunk husband takes away her earnings. How are things different in both cases I wonder. The difference is that she willingly lets it be this way, while the maid would probably fight to save her earning. She actually had to ask her husband before purchasing things and request him to pay for them. To be honest we have only one earning member in our family at present, and we do consult each other before non-essential purchases, but it is not about seeking permission ever. I could not believe what I saw. Such things in modern, urban living?
There was more to follow. The man drinks and regularly too. He loves to drink, and so the DH and he make good drinking buddies. I guess friends are meant for that, hanging around, over some drinks. Which was all well, till the night I wanted a drink too. After an entire day of running around, and managing two little brats, I wanted to unwind. I suggested that glasses be poured out for me and the lady too, since it was Vodka that night, a drink that I can handle. The woman of course in true bharatiya nari style has never even sipped a drink, so I suggested she gives it a try. The man was shocked at my brazen boldness I think. He could not say a clear no in our presence, but made it quite clear indirectly that he did not want his wife drinking. She of course obediently said no, inspite of the initial show of enthusiasm. I actually ended up letting her steal a sip off my glass, hiding from her husband. Can you imagine a grown woman, a mother having to hide and do things. There were obviously many questions about my drinking, but the first took the cake, because of the shocked surprise in which the DH was asked, "She drinks?". I think this irritated the DH more than it did me. They were seriously shocked that I drank. I actually got all defensive and finally said, I hardly ever drink. I regret that now. How can anyone drink and think it is ok for him to do so, but not his wife. Such hypocritical double standards. Disgusting.
What bothers me most is that the woman quietly accepts all of this, and does not even think there is anything wrong with the way things are. There can be no change, till she demands it and moreimportantly wants it.I have come to realise that academic education alone will not help liberate women, there has to be an opening up of the minds too. Its the self understanding and acceptance that is needed. A million degrees would not ensure that the person actually realises what women's liberation means. I really had higher hopes from the urban Indian woman, I had thought she has travelled to much greater heights than this. This is just not acceptable. We cannot accept being trampled.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)

19 comments:
GM, that's what I have problem with too. Hypocrisy. It is not about drinks or clothes. It is about individual choice. I mean if someone doesn't want to drink then that's her choice but how is it okay that husband drinks and expects that his wife shouldn't touch that evil.
Women's liberation definitely doesn't mean all this but then simple question is why is it okay for one gender to smoke, drink, wear anything and say anything and still get away with all whereas when we send chaddis we are ridiculed. When we drink or go to pub we are asked not to because men might get high seeing us.
We see 3 months and 1 year old girls getting molested. Now do these tiny tots do anything to make them high?
Hypocrisy is what I can't stand and that's one reason I started supporting Pink chaddi campaign which I wasn't sure about in the beginning.
whoa! That`s so sad! But then, such double standards exist everywhere. You know I picked up smoking a couple of years back. But even know, it takes guts to accept that publicly. People who see me smoking imdtly assume I must be sleeping around as well! While there are friends of mine who insist I quit(including the G who doesnt smoke!) because of health concerns, there are these other 'friends' who insist I quit because its not befitting of an Indian woman! You know, it angers me so much that I want to continue, just as a rebellion to morons of these kinds!
You know.. its such a coincidence... I was thinking along similar lines this past one week and had discussions with another friend...
But, I still haven't found time to blog about all of this...
I will write about it and will link you up as well...
Brilliantly written as always :)
''A million degrees would not ensure that the person actually realises what women's liberation means. ''
Proud to have you on my blogroll:)
Let me second Solilo and say PCC is all about challenging the hypocrisy too..It just disgusts me..
Wonderful post! We see women like these everywhere, GM.
I know of an affluent joint business family (parents, two sons and their families) where both the sons give their earnings to their mother and not keep it for themselves or their families, and the mother gives them a pre-allocated amount to run the monthly expenses. Of course, whenever they want something out of the 'regular' monthly purchases (stuff for kids, stuff for wives), they ask the mother and she gives them the money without a fuss.
The women are decked in high-end fashion and expensive jewellery at all times. The kids, all of them, have laptops and PSPs and iPods, expensive mobile phones, and cars for the older ones. The entire family has six cars in totality. Each family goes on a foreign trip once or twice a year and on in-country holidays every two months, usually aboard luxury cruise liners and always staying in expensive hotels around the world. But despite all the riches and luxuries, they have no control over their earning from the family business.
When I first heard of it, I was stunned. I mean, WTF? It is like giving pocket-money to kids. And the men in question have two kids each of their own (two of the four kids go to college)!
The reason given to justify this behaviour is that the mother does not want any difference in the lifestyles and status of te two daughters-in-law, so she gives them equal amount of money to spend. Whenever one buys jewellery or clothes or whatever, the mother gets the same for the other daughter-in-law too. Same for the men and their kids. So apart from controlling finances, they control the lifestyles, too. I wonder how this leads to equality or anything. I mean, if DIL 1 gets a Tanishq neckpiece but DIL 2 doesn't want one, will the latter get it forcibly, just because the former got it for herself? It is stupid and ridiculous to the point of being hilarious. LOL...
sounds bad very bad ...
She can't demand because than he will not respect her. I have seen this happen, respect is a huge control tool. If she did this unladylike thing she will be oh so undignified, and he who drinks himself would not be able to respect her!
Anti Pink Chaddi Campaign people say the same kind of thing.
Solilo - Definitely! Hypocricy is what this is all about. Woman's liberation is about a woman doing what she wants to do,whatever that is, without any restrictions.
Piper - You should never quit because you are a woman, but you should quit because it is terribly hazardous to your health.
Pixcie - Thank You. :D Write up soon.
Indyeah - Ofcourse it does,double standards are just disgusting.
Surbhi - Very true. How scary must it be, to have no control over your own life, no matter how many luxuries you are offered.
UI - It is.
IHM - Oh yes, the controlling chip. So many people use it!!
hey.. I blogrolled you too! :) there`s something wrong with my comment section. I cant reply now. But shall, later.
And yes, I`m trying, my friend :( Its not easy!
i just realized it must be 3:30AM at Dubai!!!! what on earth are doing at this hour???!!!!!!!!!!
Piper - i know it is very very tough.
I am up at this time because the BB was refusing to sleep. He has just fallen asleep, and I still have work pending imagine. And not even time to blog, just catching up on reading what I missed teh last week. ;) You on g-talk or something? I am on as goofymumma.
Hi, came here from Piper's. Great blog! :)
The incident you mention demonstrates something I hate and keep writing about - men expecting women to live up to certain ideals of womanhood that they have defined. And women, due to conditioning, societal pressures, desire to be loved/respected by the men in their lives - doing just that and forgetting to be themselves. I've come across many such things, too, at parties and social gatherings - men and women congregating in separate groups, men being served ahead of women - and no one seems to speak up against these. Nice post.
ohh.. I guess I missed ya. Lord! I dunno how you do it. I`m getting nervous thinking i`ll have to be up by 6 tomorrow! :)
Mystic - Hi, welcome and thanks. Yes it is that way, and it is so much a part of life now, that most people don't even notice it. As long as a woman does something because she wants to, its just fine, even if that is fasting on all 7 days of the week, the problem is when she is forced to do things in the name of honour/dignity/ tradition or even progress for that matter.
Piper - I wake up real late lady, i am a night bird through and through.
This is 'urban Indian woman, GM ... imagine the non-urban woman ... who the moral police is targeting for votes.
it's sad that most of women in our country are still immersed in self-destruction and deluded campaigns like pcc are taking shape.
awesome post.
A comment on this topic is something which cannot be written in 3-4 lines like this.
Its too complex...........u r talking abt a way of life which has been followed for eons b4 this....this attitude is inside the man...in his genes. It will take another 2 generation of literacy & free thinking to complete remove it from India...:-)).
I came to a similar realisation about education a while ago, but it was the cultural discrimination in the UAE that led me to it, not so much gender discrimination. You may be a PhD, hold several degrees and yet, your mind could still be only as wide as a drain pipe & probably as filthy too.
Only now am I realising why schools include subjects like 'value education' and 'moral science' ..... but the sad thing is these subjects are treated like a joke not only by students, but by teachers too. People tend to focus on academic progress so much that other equally important things like moral development tend to get sidelined, whereas if you start inculcating values from childhood itself, you're more likely to turn out well-rounded adults.
I am shocked to be reminded of such instances where woman doesn't have control over what she earns. But I am not surprised. Sad that is.
You know GM, as you rightly said, it's not just about the education and degrees, it also about an opening of minds and widening viewpoints. And here, I am not just talking about women, but men. It is up to moms like us to broaden the horizons for our sons.
Post a Comment